Is There A Grandfather Clause For Registered

This editorial cartoon from a January 1879 edition of Harper's Weekly pokes fun at the apply of literacy tests for blacks every bit voting qualifications. Wikimedia Eatables hide explanation

toggle caption

Wikimedia Commons

People aren't exempted from new regulations because they're old and crotchety, fifty-fifty if that'southward what information technology sounds like when we say they're "grandfathered in."

The term "grandfathered" has become part of the linguistic communication. Information technology'south an like shooting fish in a barrel style to describe individuals or companies who get to proceed operating under an existing set of expectations when new rules are put in place.

The troubled HealthCare.gov website reassures consumers that they tin can stay enrolled in grandfathered insurance plans that existed before the Affordable Intendance Act was enacted in 2010. Onetime ability plants are sometimes grandfathered from having to run into new clean air requirements.

Merely like so many things, the term "granddaddy," used in this fashion, has its roots in America's racial history. It entered the lexicon non just because it suggests something one-time, but because of a specific set of 19th century laws regulating voting.

The 15th Subpoena, which prohibited racial discrimination in voting, was ratified by us in 1870. If yous know your history, yous'll realize that African-Americans were nevertheless kept from voting in big numbers in Southern states for most a century more.

Various states created requirements — literacy tests and poll taxes and constitutional quizzes — that were designed to keep blacks from registering to vote. But many poor Southern whites were at take chances of also losing their rights because they could not accept met such expectations.

"If all these white people are going to be noncitizens along with blacks, the idea is going to lose a lot of support," says James Smethurst, who teaches African-American studies at the Academy of Massachusetts.

The solution? A half-dozen states passed laws that made men eligible to vote if they had been able to vote earlier African-Americans were given the franchise (generally, 1867), or if they were the lineal descendants of voters back then.

This was called the grandpa clause. Most such laws were enacted in the early 1890s.

"The grandad clause is actually non a means of disenfranchising anybody," says Michael Klarman, a Harvard law professor. "It was a means of enfranchising whites who might accept been excluded by things like literacy clauses. It was politically necessary, because otherwise you'd have as well much opposition from poor whites who would have been disenfranchised."

Merely protecting whites from restrictions meant to utilise to African-Americans was manifestly another form of bigotry itself.

"Because of the 15th Subpoena, you tin't laissez passer laws saying blacks tin can't vote, which is what they wanted to practice," says Eric Foner, a Columbia University historian. "Only the 15th Amendment allowed restrictions that were nonracial. This was pretty prima facie a way to allow whites to vote, and not blacks."

Some state legislatures enacted grandfather clauses despite knowing they couldn't pass constitutional muster. The Louisiana state ramble convention adopted a grandfather clause fifty-fifty though one of the state'south own U.Southward. senators warned it would exist "grossly unconstitutional."

For that reason, nearly every state put a time limit on their grandfather clauses. They hoped to get whites registered earlier these laws could be challenged in court.

"One time you've got people removed from the rolls, it becomes less necessary," Smethurst says. "The white people are on the rolls, and the black people are non."

African-Americans typically lacked the financial resources to file accommodate. The NAACP, founded in 1909, persuaded a U.South. attorney to challenge Oklahoma's grandfather clause, which had been enacted in 1910.

Of the more than than 55,000 blacks who were in Oklahoma in 1900, only 57 came from states that had permitted African-Americans to vote in 1867, co-ordinate to Klarman's book From Jim Crow to Civil Rights: The Supreme Court and the Struggle for Racial Equality.

In 1915, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously in Guinn v. United states of america that grandfather clauses were unconstitutional. The court in those days upheld whatever number of segregationist laws — and even in Guinn specified that literacy tests untethered from granddad clauses were OK.

The justices were concerned that the grandfather clause was non just discriminatory but a clear effort by a land to nullify the federal Constitution. It "was so obvious an evasion that the Supreme Court could not have failed to declare information technology unconstitutional," The Washington Post wrote at the time.

The decision had almost no effect, however. The Oklahoma Legislature met in special session to grandfather in the grandfather clause. The new law said those who had been registered in 1914 — whites under the old system — were automatically registered to vote, while African-Americans could only register between Apr xxx and May 11, 1916, or forever be disenfranchised.

That police stayed on the books until a Supreme Court ruling in 1939.

The intent of the grandfather clause, however, was not strictly to placate some whites while discriminating confronting blacks, says Spencer Overton, author of Stealing Republic: The New Politics of Voter Suppression. It was also virtually ability.

In that era, most African-Americans voted Republican, the party of Abraham Lincoln.

"The whole objective of excluding African-Americans was not simply white supremacy," Overton says. "It was, 'Nosotros're Democrats; they're Republicans; and we're going to exclude them.' I'm non saying in that location weren't racial overtones, but at that place were significant partisan overtones as well."

The same trick had been used against white immigrants in the Northeast. It'south worth remembering that Massachusetts and Connecticut were the first states to impose literacy tests, in hopes of keeping immigrants — who often supported Democrats in a largely Republican region — from voting.

At least one grandfather clause in the Due south was based on a Massachusetts statute from 1857, says Overton, who teaches police force at George Washington University.

Possibly it's because the grandfather clause was not solely about race — and because it was banned a century agone — most people use the term "grandfathered in" and never realize information technology once had racial connotations.

"This term 'grandfather' has been kind of deracialized," Overton says. "It's really a very convenient, shorthand term. We probably would not exist as comfy with using it if nosotros associated it with grandfather clauses in the past and poll taxes and things like that."